Indigenous views enter a realm where gender transcends boundaries and different binaries. It offers a profound perspective on gender fluidity shaped by cultural norms, spirituality and traditions. Through residential schools and the Canadian government’s attempt at assimilating native peoples, it would be hard to imagine a world without their influence. Yet that too seems slightly impossible now that we will begin to understand how the influence of indigenous peoples impacts the modern world we live in today. Exploring self-expression through the lens of indigenous societies in “The Dawn of Everything” we can see its original impact and how it could impact Glenn Gears and Shane Ortega through their experiences of indigenous self-expression. I will be exploring how indigenous cultures defied gender norms the European settlers had contrasting them and their ongoing impact on modern society. In this blog, I will be discussing how gender and cultural diversity in the early contact period allowed people like Glenn and Shane to start exploring their individuality and identity.
Before we try and dissect how Shane and Glenn found their identities we must examine the footprint that allowed them to explore that path. David Wengrow and David Graber make it extremely clear that there was no inequality between men and women among the indigenous communities the settlers were in contact with. This concept is important to understand as it is the basis of one of the main differences in comparison to the Europeans. Although indigenous men and women were assigned different tasks none of them were assigned based on gender, marital duties or cultural expectations. Things like caring for children was equally seen as a man’s task in native society as it was for a woman; completely contrasting the assigned gender roles of the settlers which would entail a woman’s job is primarily to raise the children. This was one of many shocks the settlers would face, the next being the rejection of paternalism. In Europe, paternalism was the adopted “culture”. It was because of a man’s power and more relevant place in society that he was the centre of the household. Potentially men of high status had a power trip and that is why paternalism was the only acceptable thing. High-ranking men in the church and government possess positions of power which felt as if it was a man’s job to be the centre of the household because a man is traditionally strong and typically the breadwinner. Suggesting that it could never be a woman’s place to be a breadwinner or uphold a family. ironically when under the settlers mentality, the women would quite literally make sure the family was upheld. Contrary to the indigenous groups met by these settlers who were predominantly matrilineal. Indigenous societies were able to equally value important women who led the clans all while equally distributing power to the men. Them being matrilineal did not take away from the men in their society, unlike the patrilineal ways of the Europeans which assigned clear and lesser gender roles to the women. The importance of “The Dawn of Everything” is the rejection of not only gender roles but more Western binaries. “One of the key ways that difference has often been delineated is gender.” (Keough 17). So in broader terms, the main difference between the two is how they both perceive gender. The Europeans see it as definitive of an individual’s place socially and politically, whereas the First Nations see it as more of an identity instead of an assigned role by society. Having the latter point of view allows native people to explore their individuality and be somewhat genderfluid. With this area of self-expression, some native people consider themselves two-spirit.
Shane Ortega was kicked out of the US military after starting his transition during Trump’s 2016 election. Shane also identifies as two-spirit. Being two-spirit for Shane meant that he was fluid within his own identity. Two-spirit is an umbrella term for native LGBTQ+ people who are both masculine and feminine. Being indigenous allowed Shane to discover his heritage and allow himself to heal his traumas through spiritual practices such as the sun dance he demonstrated during the documentary. Shane deeply expresses that he feels the decolonization of America is linked to the deterioration of his rights as a trans person. Before settlers came to America there was a place for trans people within society. way back when Shane explained that being trans was seen as sacred and the artwork of a Sioux warrior with a trans woman was seen as normal. In the very beginning of the documentary where we met Shane talks about awareness within the indigenous community and decolonisation. He brings up remembering how there are as indigenous people in their respective areas. He mentions how no matter which political party anyone takes place in, even if advocating for a more liberal party that would accept various identities, they are both representations of colonisation for those who are indigenous. Shane explains that no matter what government takes over America it’s a force that forcefully took this land from native people in 1492. It makes no difference whether it is Trump or Trudeau in the eyes of indigenous peoples because it was always their land yet their rights and cultures have been continuously repressed by the consequences of colonisation.
Sometime after colonisation when the settlers decided they no longer felt inspired by indigenous ideas but rather threatened, the Canadian government attempted to assimilate all indigenous children through residential schools. Children were stripped from their parents at a young age, forced to cut their hair which was sacred and punished for speaking their mother tongue. Not to mention all the sexual, physical and mental abuse these children faced. Residential schools to this day have generational impacts on those who come after, like Glenn Gears. He shared during his presentation that his mother was of Irish descent but his indigenous father faced the horrors of residential schools. For reasons his father most likely did not know his family and felt extreme trauma when asked about his culture so consequently Glenn never grew to learn about his heritage. Because cultural expression was not possible for Glen generationally, the little he did learn in the years to come Glenn expresses his identity as indigi-queer through art. His art is a reflection of his learning to navigate his newfound identity through self-expression in art. The pieces he created allowed him to visit family and reconnect with his native roots which were forcibly detached from his earlier life. Through these works, he can learn more about himself and his culture allowing him to explore his self-expression through indigenous societies.
By beginning to understand the First Nations outlook on gender and cultural diversity we can understand the core ideas that allow individuals within the indigenous community to explore self-expression. People like Shane Ortega and Glenn Gears are a reflection of the initial indigenous people’s mindset when the settlers first arrived. By understanding the original societies, we see how their mindset is formative for those who came after even in the modern world. So conclusively, there are many examples discussed earlier in this blog that elaborate on the impact of indigenous societies that are still felt. Culturally there are still so many people connected. Spiritually it is still there within indigenous communities. But most importantly it is still of major influence when exploring self-expression through the lens of indigenous values.
Bibliography:
Glenn Gear, presenter. 29 Apr. 2024, Montreal, Vanier College.
Keough, Willeen G. and Lara Campbell “Gender and Cultural Diversity in the Early Contact Period.” Gender History: Canadian Perspectives, Oxford University Press, 2014, pp. 16-28
Zosherafatain, Tony. “Trans in Trumpland: Idaho.” Kanopy, The Film Sales Company,
http://www.kanopy.com/en/vaniercollege/video/11561418. Accessed 29 Apr. 2024.